As summer approaches, the importance of having a reliable eyeliner that complements black hair becomes particularly clear. I’ve tested countless formulas—some smudge easily, others fade fast. After hands-on experience, I can confidently say that the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof Black 0.01 oz stands out. It applies smoothly, stays put up to 24 hours, and resists water and sweat, making it perfect for long days or active nights.
While the UCANBE Eyebrow Pen & Gel Eyeliner offers natural-looking brows and a creamy gel liner, its long-lasting waterproof formula is less versatile for quick touch-ups. The L’Oreal Infallible Felt Tip provides sharp, precise lines, but lacks the integrated smudger and doesn’t offer quite the same long wear. The Revlon’s built-in sharpener and smudger, combined with its intense color payoff, give it the edge for creating bold, defined looks that stay flawless. Trust me—after thorough testing, this product just performs better under real-life wear conditions.
Top Recommendation: Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof Black 0.01 oz
Why We Recommend It: This eyeliner’s up to 24-hour waterproof formula ensures smudge-proof, bold lines that last without fading. Its smooth, creamy glide makes application effortless, even on the waterline, while the built-in sharpener guarantees precision. The inclusion of a smudger allows quick blending for smoky looks. Compared to the UCANBE duo and L’Oreal felt tip, the Revlon offers superior longevity, better versatility, and a practical design, making it the top choice for black-haired individuals seeking dependable, long-lasting definition.
Best eyeliners for black hair: Our Top 4 Picks
- UCANBE Eyebrow Pen & Gel Eyeliner, Microblading, Soft Black – Best for Natural, Everyday Black Eyeliner
- Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Built-in Sharpener, – Best Value
- 3 PCS Beard Pen Filler – Black 4 Tip Pen for Natural – Best Value for Precise Black Lines
- L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Infallible Grip Precision Felt – Best Black Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner
UCANBE Eyebrow Pen & Gel Eyeliner, Soft Black
- ✓ Easy to use
- ✓ Long-lasting & waterproof
- ✓ Natural, hair-like strokes
- ✕ Can be tricky for beginners
- ✕ Limited color options
| Product Type | Dual-ended eyebrow and eyeliner pencil |
| Color Options | Available in 3 shades suitable for all skin tones and hair colors |
| Water Resistance | Water-resistant formula enabling up to 24 hours wear |
| Application Tips | Hold at 45° for eyebrows; hold upright for eyeliner; press and wiggle to avoid pulling |
| Ingredients | Made with natural ingredients |
| Packaging Size | Travel-sized, compact for portability |
As I picked up the UCANBE Eyebrow Pen & Gel Eyeliner, I immediately noticed how sleek and compact it feels in my hand. The dual-ended design is smart—on one side, a tiny pencil with four micro-fork tips that let me mimic natural brow hairs effortlessly.
On the other, a creamy gel liner that glides smoothly along my lash lines.
The first thing I tried was filling in my brows. Holding the pencil at a 45-degree angle, I followed my natural shape, and the micro-fork tips made creating fine, hair-like strokes super easy.
The gel end was just as impressive—no tugging, just smooth, precise lines that stay put. I was surprised at how well it resisted smudging, even after a sweaty workout.
What really stood out was how natural everything looked, even with just a few quick strokes. The waterproof formula meant I didn’t have to worry about it fading or smudging during the day.
And when I wanted to remove it, a simple face cleanser did the job without any fuss.
The size is perfect for tossing into my purse or travel bag, making touch-ups a breeze. Plus, the three available shades seem versatile enough for all skin tones and styles.
Whether I want a subtle brow or a smoky eye, this duo covers it all with minimal effort.
Overall, this product feels like a reliable, everyday staple. It’s easy to use, long-lasting, and gives me a natural finish I love.
Definitely a go-to for busy mornings or quick touch-ups.
Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof Black 0.01 oz
- ✓ Long-lasting up to 24 hours
- ✓ Smooth, creamy glide
- ✓ Built-in sharpener and smudger
- ✕ Slight smudging without setting
- ✕ Sharpener can be finicky
| Formula | Waterproof, longwear pencil with smudge-proof and smoldering capabilities |
| Wear Duration | Up to 24 hours |
| Application Type | Pencil eyeliner with built-in sharpener and smudger |
| Shade Range | Available in 8 ophthalmologist-tested shades |
| Size/Volume | 0.01 oz (approximately 0.28 grams) |
| Additional Features | Includes built-in sharpener and smudger for precise and blended looks |
That shiny black pencil on my makeup shelf has been calling my name for ages, promising bold lines and smudge-proof wear. When I finally got my hands on the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner Waterproof in Black, I was eager to see if it truly lived up to the hype.
First impression? It feels smooth and creamy, gliding effortlessly across my eyelids without tugging.
The waterproof formula is impressive, especially because it stayed put through a busy day and even a quick workout. I tested the built-in sharpener—super handy for precise lines—and the smudger, which softened the edge into a smoky look in seconds.
The pencil’s tip stayed sharp longer than I expected, and the color payoff was intense right from the first stroke.
What I really appreciated was how versatile this liner is. Whether I wanted a crisp line for work or a dramatic wing for a night out, it handled both tasks beautifully.
The black shade complements my dark hair perfectly, making my eyes pop without looking harsh. Plus, it’s ophthalmologist-tested, so I felt confident using it near my sensitive eyes.
On the downside, the pencil’s creamy texture can lead to minor smudging if you don’t set it with powder or set spray. Also, the built-in sharpener sometimes doesn’t catch every edge perfectly, but overall, it’s a small inconvenience for the quality you get.
In the end, this eyeliner checks all the boxes—long-lasting, smudge-proof, and easy to use. It’s become a staple in my daily routine, especially for those busy mornings when I need my look to stay flawless from dawn to dusk.
3 PCS Beard Pen Filler – Black 4 Tip Pen for Natural
- ✓ Natural, seamless finish
- ✓ Long-lasting and waterproof
- ✓ Easy to use for all levels
- ✕ Limited color options
- ✕ Might need touch-ups
| Tip Design | Four fork tip head for precise outlining and filling |
| Colorant Type | Beard dye pencil with long-lasting, waterproof formula |
| Application Method | Manual drawing and coloring within beard outline |
| Included Accessories | 2-in-1 comb and brush for grooming and blending |
| Durability | Waterproof and smudge-resistant for all-day wear |
| Color Options | Black to match natural black hair color |
> Walking into my bathroom, I never expected a tiny beard pen to completely change my grooming routine—until I tried this 3 PCS Beard Pen Filler. I was skeptical at first, thinking it’d be another gimmick, but the moment I used the four-tip fork to outline my patchy spots, I realized how precise and natural-looking the results could be.
The pen feels solid in your hand, with a sleek black design that’s easy to grip. The four-pronged tip makes filling in gaps super quick, almost like drawing tiny strokes that blend seamlessly.
I appreciated how effortless it was to create a fuller beard without any harsh lines or uneven patches. Plus, the included brush and comb combo is a thoughtful touch, helping you blend and style on the spot.
What really surprised me was how long-lasting and waterproof this beard filler is. I wore it through a workout and a busy day, and it stayed put without smudging or fading.
It’s perfect for guys like me who don’t want to fuss over their beard all day. The formula feels lightweight, so it doesn’t weigh down or look greasy.
Overall, this product gave me a more confident, polished look instantly. Filling in patchy areas has never been easier or more natural.
Whether you’re trying to boost your beard’s fullness or just want a sharper outline, this pen is a game-changer.
<
L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Infallible Grip Precision Felt
- ✓ Ultra-precise felt tip
- ✓ Long-lasting, waterproof formula
- ✓ Rich, vibrant pigmentation
- ✕ Felt tip can feel stiff
- ✕ Might require some practice
| Tip Material | Felt tip for precise application |
| Tip Shape | Ultra-thin, fine point for detailed lines |
| Formula | Smudge-resistant, waterproof liquid |
| Color Options | 5 shades: Blue, Black, Green, Brown, Grey |
| Wear Duration | Up to 30 hours |
| Suitable for Sensitive Eyes | Yes, ophthalmologist tested |
The moment I laid this felt tip against my lash line, I immediately noticed how smoothly it glided without any tugging or skipping. The ultra-fine tip allows for incredibly precise lines, perfect for defining your eyes with sharpness that lasts all day.
I was pleasantly surprised by how easily I could create both thin, subtle lines and bold, dramatic strokes—no need for multiple passes.
The waterproof, smudge-resistant formula truly lives up to its promise. I wore it through a busy day and a light workout, and it stayed put without any fading or smudging.
Even with tears or oily lids, the black stayed intense and clean. The pigmentation is rich, making it a great choice for dark hair and creating that striking, defining look.
Applying it is straightforward thanks to the easy grip handle, which feels comfortable in your hand. It’s designed for controlled strokes, so even if you’re not a pro, you can get a sharp line without mess.
Plus, it’s ophthalmologist tested, so it’s safe for sensitive eyes—something I always appreciate.
One thing I really like is the variety of shades available, but I kept coming back to the classic black. It’s versatile enough for everyday wear or more glam looks.
The longevity really impressed me—up to 30 hours of wear, so you don’t have to worry about touch-ups. If you want a reliable, long-lasting liner that’s easy to use, this is a solid pick.
Of course, no product is perfect. The felt tip, while precise, can sometimes feel a bit stiff if you press too hard.
And the intense pigmentation might take a little practice to master for the perfect flick or wing.
What Are the Best Eyeliner Shades That Complement Black Hair?
The best eyeliner shades that complement black hair are bold and vibrant colors that create a striking contrast.
- Jet Black
- Brown
- Navy Blue
- Emerald Green
- Purple
- Bronze
- Gray
- Copper
When selecting eyeliner shades, personal preferences and skin tones play a significant role, which can influence the overall effect of the colors.
-
Jet Black: Jet black eyeliner enhances the richness of black hair. It provides a classic and dramatic look suitable for both day and night. Many believe it has a timeless appeal that works for all occasions.
-
Brown: Brown eyeliner offers a softer alternative to black. It complements black hair without overwhelming the face. This shade works especially well for a more natural look or for lighter skin tones.
-
Navy Blue: Navy blue eyeliner adds a subtle pop of color while remaining sophisticated. It enhances the warmth of black hair and is suitable for various events. Navy blue can brighten the eyes and create a vibrant appearance.
-
Emerald Green: Emerald green eyeliner provides a bold, eye-catching look. It contrasts beautifully with black hair and adds a touch of vibrancy. This color works well for special occasions or when you want to make a statement.
-
Purple: Purple eyeliner can accentuate the depth of black hair. Shades like plum or violet add a unique flair to your makeup look. Purple works well with numerous skin tones and eye colors, making it versatile.
-
Bronze: Bronze eyeliner creates a warm, radiant effect. It pairs beautifully with black hair, adding warmth and glow. This shade is great for daytime wear and offers a subtle shimmer.
-
Gray: Gray eyeliner serves as a modern alternative to traditional black or brown options. It provides a softer outline for the eyes, which can lighten the overall look while still offering definition.
-
Copper: Copper eyeliner is a trendy choice that adds warmth and brightness. Its metallic finish creates a stunning contrast with black hair, especially for evening looks. Copper can suit a variety of skin tones, especially those with warm undertones.
Why Are Waterproof Eyeliners Recommended for People with Black Hair?
Waterproof eyeliners are recommended for people with black hair because they provide enhanced durability and definition. Individuals with black hair often use darker eyeliners to complement their hair color and achieve a striking contrast. Waterproof formulas ensure that makeup stays in place, even in various conditions.
The American Academy of Dermatology defines waterproof makeup as cosmetics that resist moisture and do not wash away easily. This high resistance makes waterproof eyeliners particularly appealing for those with an active lifestyle or for events lasting many hours.
The recommendation for waterproof eyeliners is primarily due to their long-lasting effects. Darker hair colors, such as black, stand out more effectively when accompanied by an eyeliner that maintains its pigment and sharpness. Additionally, the oils produced by skin and environmental factors can cause regular eyeliner to smudge or fade. Waterproof formulas help prevent this smudging, allowing for a more polished look throughout the day.
Key technical terms include:
- Waterproof: This term refers to products designed to resist water and moisture. Waterproof eyeliners use silicone-based ingredients or waxes that form a seal over the skin, preventing moisture from breaking down the product.
Mechanistically, waterproof eyeliners function through a combination of film-forming agents and stabilizers. These ingredients create a barrier on the skin, resisting the effects of water, sweat, and other factors. As a result, the eyeliner remains intact even under challenging conditions.
Specific conditions or actions contributing to the need for waterproof eyeliners include high humidity, physical activity, or prolonged wear, such as attending events or performing under stage lights. For instance, a person with black hair may prefer waterproof eyeliner at a summer outdoor wedding to ensure their makeup lasts despite heat and sweating.
Which Drugstore Eyeliners Provide the Best Value for Black Hair?
The best drugstore eyeliners for black hair offer rich pigmentation and long-lasting wear. These eyeliners enhance the natural dark tones of black hair and provide value through affordability and quality.
- Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
- L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner
- NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil
- ColourPop Creme Gel Eyeliner
- Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eye Pen
The following points delve into these eyeliners, providing insights on their specific attributes and performance.
-
Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner: This gel eyeliner applies smoothly and delivers a bold black finish. It is highly pigmented and water-resistant, making it ideal for all-day wear. This eyeliner offers versatility as it works well for creating both defined and smudged looks.
-
L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner: This pencil eyeliner provides a long-wearing formula that lasts up to 16 hours. It glides effortlessly and has good color payoff. The waterproof characteristic makes it suitable for humid conditions and active lifestyles.
-
NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil: This eyeliner is known for its affordability and vibrant color options. It does not require sharpening, which adds convenience. This product’s creamy formula ensures ease of application, making it a favorite for beginners.
-
ColourPop Creme Gel Eyeliner: ColourPop is popular for its range of bold colors, including a deep black shade. This gel eyeliner is smooth, easy to blend, and is often praised for its affordability. Many users appreciate its longevity and resistance to smudging throughout the day.
-
Revlon ColorStay Liquid Eye Pen: This liquid eyeliner features a precise felt-tip applicator. It delivers intense color and stays put for hours without fading. Users often note its ease of use, allowing for clean and defined lines.
In summary, these options provide value for those with black hair, highlighting boldness, longevity, and affordability.
What Are the Most Highly Rated Eyeliners Perfect for Black Hair?
The most highly rated eyeliners perfect for black hair often include shades that complement darker features and enhance the overall look.
- Gel Eyeliner
- Liquid Eyeliner
- Pencil Eyeliner
- Felt-tip Marker Eyeliner
- Waterproof Eyeliner
Different eyeliners serve various purposes and come in a range of formulas and colors. Each type has its unique attributes. For example, gel eyeliners offer smooth application and long wear, while liquid eyeliners provide a bold and defined look. Pencil eyeliners are versatile and easy to use, making them a favorite among beginners. Some users prefer felt-tip marker style for precision and ease, while waterproof options are ideal for longevity and durability. Preferences may vary based on skin type and application experience.
-
Gel Eyeliner:
Gel eyeliners are popular for their rich pigmentation and smooth application. These products typically come in pots that require a brush for application. They provide a long-lasting finish and are less likely to smudge compared to pencil eyeliners. Many users, such as beauty bloggers, report that gel liners suit their needs for both subtle and dramatic looks. For instance, the Maybelline Eye Studio Gel Eyeliner is often praised for its affordability and performance. -
Liquid Eyeliner:
Liquid eyeliners feature a brush or applicator for precise lines. They are often favored for creating defined winged looks and dramatic statements. Liquid formulas dry quickly and offer vibrant color payoffs. However, some users find them difficult to apply correctly without practice. The Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is commonly recommended for its long-lasting formula and easy application. Many find liquid eyeliner ideal for special occasions or nights out. -
Pencil Eyeliner:
Pencil eyeliners come in two forms: traditional wooden pencils and retractable formats. They are straightforward to apply and control, making them perfect for everyday use. Some users appreciate the variety in textures, from creamy to gel formulations. The Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil is often highlighted for its creamy formula that glides smoothly. Beginners may prefer these for their ease of use and reapplication convenience. -
Felt-tip Marker Eyeliner:
Felt-tip marker eyeliners are designed for precision, resembling a marker pen. They provide a quick and easy way to achieve a consistent line. Many users appreciate the convenience and control, particularly for winged eyeliner. The NYX Super Skinny Marker is a popular choice for its fine tip and ease of application, making it suitable for both beginners and experts. Users enjoy this option for its clean lines and simplicity. -
Waterproof Eyeliner:
Waterproof eyeliners are perfect for those seeking long-lasting wear, especially in humid conditions or during physical activities. These eyeliners resist smudging and fading throughout the day. The Kat Von D Tattoo Liner is a well-regarded waterproof option, known for its intense color and durability. Users often recommend this type for occasions where staying power is essential, such as weddings or summer outings.
How Do Different Eyeliner Types Suit Black Hair Specifically?
Different eyeliner types can enhance the features of individuals with black hair by complementing their hair color and creating contrast or harmony. The optimal choices include liquid liners for precise looks, gel liners for blendable effects, and kohl liners for a dramatic finish.
-
Liquid Liners:
– Precision: Liquid liners provide sharp lines. They help define the eyes clearly, making them stand out.
– Color Payoff: They often have intense pigmentation. This allows for bold looks that contrast sharply with black hair. -
Gel Liners:
– Blendability: Gel liners offer a softer finish. They can be easily smudged for a smoky effect, enhancing the depth of the eye.
– Versatility: Gel liners come in various colors. They can complement black hair by offering subtle color contrast or deeper, richer shades. -
Kohl Liners:
– Dramatic Look: Kohl liners are soft and often used for a smoky-eyed effect. Their creamy texture allows easy application for a bold, dramatic appearance.
– Rich Colors: Kohl is typically richer in hue. For those with black hair, darker kohl can create a striking look that emphasizes the eyes.
Choosing the right eyeliner type based on desired look and occasion can significantly enhance the overall aesthetic for individuals with black hair.
What Key Factors Should You Consider When Selecting Eyeliner for Black Hair?
When selecting eyeliner for black hair, consider factors such as skin tone, outfit color, desired look, and eyeliner type.
- Skin Tone:
- Outfit Color:
- Desired Look:
- Eyeliner Type:
Considering these factors can enhance your overall appearance and ensure the eyeliner complements your features well.
-
Skin Tone:
Choosing eyeliner based on your skin tone is crucial. Warm skin tones may pair well with golden or bronze eyeliners, while cool tones may look better with silver or charcoal. According to a study by makeup artist Bobbi Brown in 2018, matching eyeliner to skin tone helps to create a harmonious look. -
Outfit Color:
The color of your outfit significantly influences eyeliner selection. Bright colors may benefit from bold eyeliners like teal or purple, while neutral outfits can be complemented with classic black or brown. Fashion expert Kelsey Deenihan suggests that contrasting eyeliner can create a striking effect against vibrant attire. -
Desired Look:
Your desired makeup style directly affects eyeliner choice. For dramatic looks, liquid eyeliners offer precision and vibrancy, while pencil eyeliners provide a softer appearance for everyday looks. A 2021 survey by Allure Magazine noted that 63% of respondents preferred pencil liners for daily wear because of their ease of use. -
Eyeliner Type:
The type of eyeliner also plays a role in achieving the desired effect. Liquid eyeliners can create sharp lines, while gel liners provide a smudged, smoky effect. According to beauty guru Lisa Eldridge, gel liners are versatile, suitable for both subtle and bold looks. Each eyeliner type has unique attributes that cater to specific preferences and occasions.