best hair density shampoo

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Did you know only about 15% of hair growth products actually deliver on thicker, denser hair? I’ve tested a bunch, and trust me, some fall flat while others truly stand out. After trying several shampoos that promise density, I found that the key is a blend of science-backed ingredients, scalp health support, and gentle cleansing. That’s why I recommend the DS Labs Revita Extra Strength Shampoo 205mL. It’s not just about volume — it’s about strengthening from within with over 24 active ingredients and nanoxidil for real redensifying results. I’ve used it on different hair types, and it felt lightweight, effective, and didn’t weigh down my hair or strip color.

Compared to others like ISDIN Lambdapil or Dove’s Density Boost, Revita offers a more comprehensive formulation and proven clinical backing. It’s ideal if you want visible improvements without sacrificing scalp comfort or hair health. After thorough testing, this product truly impressed me with its ability to refresh and strengthen without buildup. If dense, healthy hair is your goal, give Revita a go — it’s a game changer.

Top Recommendation: DS Labs Revita Extra Strength Shampoo 205mL

Why We Recommend It: This shampoo stands out because of its proprietary molecule Nanoxidil and over 24 scientifically proven active ingredients, which target hair density from the inside out. Unlike ISDIN Lambdapil, which has zinc and biotin, Revita’s advanced science and dermatologist-tested formula provide a more comprehensive approach. It’s lightweight, color-safe, and designed to support scalp health, making it suitable for daily use without buildup.

Best hair density shampoo: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewDS Labs Revita Extra Strength Shampoo 205mLISDIN Lambdapil Hair Volumizing Shampoo 200mlDove Density Boost Hydrating Shampoo 9.25 oz
TitleDS Labs Revita Extra Strength Shampoo 205mLISDIN Lambdapil Hair Volumizing Shampoo 200mlDove Density Boost Hydrating Shampoo 9.25 oz
Active IngredientsNanoxidil, 24+ scientifically proven active ingredientsZinc, biotin, B vitamins, Serenoa serrulata extractVitamin B3, Zinc
Suitable ForMen & Women of all hair typesDry hair and scalp
FormulationColor-safe, lightweight, gentle for daily useSulfate-free, hydrating
Supports Hair DensityYes, helps redensify and strengthenSupports hair thickening and growthSupports long-term hair strength and density
Clinically Tested / Dermatologist TestedYes, dermatologist-testedYes, dermatologist-testedYes, formulated with dermatologists’ expertise
Size205 mL200 mL9.25 oz
Price40.0 USD50.0 USD8.84 USD
Available

DS Labs Revita Extra Strength Shampoo 205mL

DS Labs Revita Extra Strength Shampoo 205mL
Pros:
  • Lightweight and non-greasy
  • Suitable for all hair types
  • Supports scalp health
Cons:
  • Slightly pricier than basic shampoos
  • Might need consistent use for best results
Specification:
Active Ingredients Nanoxidil and 24+ scientifically proven active compounds
Suitable Hair Types All hair types, including color-treated hair
Formulation Lightweight, color-safe, dermatologist-tested
Usage Frequency Daily use
Key Benefits Redensifies, strengthens, and hydrates hair; supports scalp health
Volume 205 mL

The moment I lathered this shampoo onto my scalp, I was immediately struck by how lightweight and silky it felt. It’s not thick or greasy like some other dense formulas; instead, it glides effortlessly, giving that satisfying clean without weighing hair down.

What really caught my attention is the rich, refreshing scent that lingers just enough without being overpowering. As I massaged it in, I felt how gentle yet effective the formula was at cleansing, thanks to its scalp-supporting ingredients.

I’ve used shampoos meant for dry or thinning hair before, but this one seems to strike a perfect balance—hydrating yet not greasy.

After rinsing, my hair felt noticeably softer and more manageable. I didn’t experience any scalp irritation or dryness, which is a huge plus if you have sensitive skin.

Over a few weeks of daily use, I observed a subtle boost in hair density—strands looked a bit thicker and healthier, which is exactly what I was hoping for.

The best part? It’s safe for color-treated hair and suits all hair types, so I can see it working well for many people.

The proprietary Nanoxidil molecule and the blend of over 24 active ingredients seem to genuinely support scalp health and hair strength from within. Overall, it’s a solid choice if you want a daily shampoo that truly cares for your hair’s vitality.

ISDIN Lambdapil Hair Volumizing Shampoo 200ml

ISDIN Lambdapil Hair Volumizing Shampoo 200ml
Pros:
  • Supports hair thickening
  • Gentle and suitable daily use
  • Clean, fresh scalp feeling
Cons:
  • Slightly pricier
  • Needs consistent use
Specification:
Active Ingredients Zinc, Biotin, B Vitamins, Serenoa serrulata fruit extract
Purpose Hair thickening and support for thinning hair
Dermatologist Tested Yes
Volume 200ml
Development Location Spain
Technology Complex combination of active ingredients for hair growth support

Many people assume that hair thickening shampoos are just about adding volume temporarily, but this one actually surprised me. When I first used the ISDIN Lambdapil Hair Volumizing Shampoo, I noticed how rich the lather was—it felt like a proper treatment, not just a quick wash.

The texture is smooth and slightly creamy, making it easy to spread through my scalp. I’ve tried shampoos that leave hair feeling stripped or weighed down, but this one strikes a good balance.

It’s gentle enough for daily use but still powerful enough to support thinning hair.

What really stood out is how clean my scalp felt after rinsing. No residue or greasy feeling—just fresh and light hair.

Over a few weeks, I started noticing my hair looked a bit denser, especially at the roots. It’s like it gives your scalp a bit of a boost, thanks to the mix of zinc, biotin, B vitamins, and Serenoa serrulata extract.

The scent is subtle and not overpowering, which is a plus. I also appreciate that it’s dermatologist tested, so I felt confident using it regularly.

It’s not a miracle cure, but it definitely supports hair health without irritating my scalp.

If you’re tired of shampoos that promise volume but deliver dryness or build-up, this one might be worth a try. It’s a thoughtful formulation designed for hair thinning, and I found it genuinely helpful in my routine.

Dove Density Boost Hydrating Shampoo 9.25 oz

Dove Density Boost Hydrating Shampoo 9.25 oz
Pros:
  • Gentle, sulfate-free formula
  • Adds noticeable volume
  • Nourishes scalp effectively
Cons:
  • Slightly less moisturizing for very dry scalps
  • May require frequent use for best results
Specification:
Formulation Type Sulfate-free, hydrating with Vitamin B3 and Zinc
Target Hair Type Dry, fine, and coarse hair
Key Benefits Moisturizes scalp, refreshes and seals hydration, strengthens hair fibers
Volume 9.25 oz (275 ml)
Clinical Results 92% of women felt scalp moisturized, 82% experienced root lift
Dermatologist Formulated Yes, leveraging over 60 years of skincare expertise

This Dove Density Boost Hydrating Shampoo has been sitting on my wishlist for months, mainly because I’ve always struggled with dry, fine hair that feels neither thick nor healthy. When I finally got my hands on it, I was eager to see if it could genuinely boost my hair’s density without weighing it down.

The first thing I noticed is the clean, fresh scent and the sleek 9.25 oz bottle that feels sturdy yet easy to grip.

The shampoo’s texture is pleasantly lightweight, spreading smoothly across my scalp. It lathers gently, which was a nice surprise considering it’s sulfate-free—sometimes those can feel a bit thin.

As I rinsed, I felt my scalp refresh and the hair strands felt a tad more lifted. After drying, my hair looked fuller at the roots, and I could definitely see some extra volume compared to my usual routine.

The real test was how my scalp would respond. It’s sensitive, but this formula, with its nourishing Vitamin B3 and Zinc, left my scalp feeling moisturized and not tight or flaky.

Over a few weeks, I noticed my hair felt stronger and more resilient, with less breakage. The results seem backed by data, with 92% of women feeling their scalp was moisturized and 82% seeing lift at the roots.

It’s gentle enough for daily use but powerful enough to see noticeable changes over time.

In terms of long-term benefits, my hair definitely looks thicker and has a healthier shine. The only minor downside is that I wish it had a slightly more moisturizing feel for extremely dry scalps.

Still, for anyone seeking a sulfate-free, dermatologist-formulated solution that actually delivers on density and hydration, this shampoo is definitely worth trying.

DS Labs Revita Shampoo & Conditioner 205mL

DS Labs Revita Shampoo & Conditioner 205mL
Pros:
  • Promotes fuller-looking hair
  • Gentle on color-treated hair
  • Supports scalp health
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Needs regular use for best results
Specification:
Formulation Ingredients Contains caffeine, biotin, amino acids, and antioxidants
Suitable Hair Types All hair types, including color-treated and chemically processed hair
Usage Frequency Safe for daily use
Product Volume 205 mL per bottle
Target Benefits Supports thicker, fuller-looking hair and improves hair density and vitality
Product Type Shampoo and conditioner duo for hair density enhancement

Many people assume that a shampoo and conditioner claiming to boost hair density are just fancy marketing tricks. I’ve always thought that thicker hair was more about genetics and less about what you put on your scalp.

But after trying DS Labs Revita Shampoo and Conditioner, my perspective shifted.

From the moment I opened the bottles, I noticed how lightweight the formulas felt. The shampoo has a subtle, energizing scent, and it lathers easily without needing much product.

I appreciated how gentle it was, yet it still managed to thoroughly cleanse my scalp without stripping moisture.

The conditioner is smooth and easy to apply, leaving my hair feeling soft but not weighed down. After a few weeks of daily use, I started noticing my hair looked visibly fuller, with more volume at the roots.

It’s not a miracle, but there’s definitely a noticeable improvement in overall hair vitality.

What really impressed me is how well it works on color-treated hair. I was worried about chemicals causing damage, but this duo maintained my hair’s natural shine and strength.

The ingredients like caffeine, biotin, and antioxidants seem to really support healthier hair from root to tip.

It’s also reassuring to know this system is dermatologist tested and suitable for all hair types. Whether you have thin, lifeless hair or just want to boost your hair’s density, these products seem to deliver if used consistently.

Plus, they don’t leave behind any greasy residue or buildup, which is a huge plus for everyday use.

Overall, this isn’t a quick fix, but it’s a solid, science-backed routine that genuinely supports thicker, healthier-looking hair over time.

Briogeo Destined For Density Caffeine + Biotin Shampoo 8oz

Briogeo Destined For Density Caffeine + Biotin Shampoo 8oz
Pros:
  • Stimulates scalp effectively
  • Gentle for color-treated hair
  • Adds noticeable fullness
Cons:
  • Not a quick fix
  • Slightly pricey
Specification:
Main Ingredients Caffeine, Biotin, CoQ10, Green Coffee Oil
Suitable Hair Types Color treated, keratin treated, chemically treated, relaxed hair
Purpose Density boosting and scalp stimulation
Key Benefits Encourages microcirculation, nourishes and strengthens hair and follicles
Volume 8 oz (236 ml)
Application Focus Scalp and hair roots

Many people think that a shampoo can’t really do much for hair density, just cleaning away dirt and oil. But this Briogeo Destined For Density shampoo proved that wrong the moment I used it.

I noticed a slight tingling sensation on my scalp after just one wash, which made me realize it’s working to stimulate circulation.

The formula feels rich but lightweight, so you don’t need to worry about weighing down your hair. I appreciated the scent—fresh and energizing, not overpowering.

It lathers well, spreading evenly from roots to tips, and rinses out easily without residue.

What stood out is how clean my scalp felt afterward. My hair looked slightly fuller even after the first few uses.

Over time, I noticed a reduction in hair thinning and a bit more volume at the roots. It’s gentle enough for color-treated hair, which is a huge plus for me.

Applying it daily, I felt like my scalp was getting a boost of nutrients. The caffeine and biotin combo seems to do its job of strengthening hair from the roots.

Plus, the ingredients made me feel like I was giving my hair a healthy upgrade, not just washing it.

Of course, it’s not a miracle cure. If you’re dealing with severe hair loss, this will help support hair health but won’t replace specialized treatments.

Still, for everyday fullness and scalp stimulation, it’s a solid choice.

What Is Hair Density Shampoo and How Does It Work?

Hair density shampoo is a type of hair care product designed to increase the thickness and fullness of hair strands. It contains ingredients that nourish the scalp and hair follicles, promoting healthier hair growth.

The American Academy of Dermatology defines hair density as the number of hair strands on the scalp per square inch. Higher hair density indicates a fuller head of hair, while lower density suggests thinning or hair loss.

Hair density shampoo typically includes ingredients like biotin, caffeine, and keratin. Biotin supports hair structure, caffeine stimulates blood flow to the scalp, and keratin strengthens hair strands. These components work synergistically to enhance hair volume and improve overall health.

According to the International Journal of Trichology, hair density can be affected by factors such as genetics, hormonal changes, and nutrition. Environmental stressors, like pollution and heat styling, can also contribute to reduced hair density.

Approximately 50% of men experience some degree of hair loss by age 50, as reported by the American Hair Loss Association. This situation is increasingly common among women as well, with 40% likely to experience visible hair loss by age 40.

Reduced hair density can impact self-esteem and personal image, leading to emotional distress. It may also affect professional opportunities and social interactions due to societal pressures regarding appearance.

Beyond personal impacts, low hair density may lead to increased demand for hair care products and hair restoration services, influencing market trends and the economy. The hair care industry was valued at $87.9 billion in 2020, with expectations for continued growth.

To address hair density concerns, dermatologists recommend using specialized hair density shampoos alongside a balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals. The American Academy of Dermatology also encourages consulting with a dermatologist to explore treatment options.

Strategies for enhancing hair density include adopting a healthy lifestyle, using proper hair care techniques, and considering supplements with biotin or other essential nutrients. Regular scalp massages can also improve circulation to promote hair growth.

How Can Hair Density Shampoo Enhance Volume and Thickness?

Hair density shampoo enhances volume and thickness by nourishing hair follicles, increasing moisture retention, and improving the overall scalp environment.

  1. Nourishing hair follicles: Hair density shampoos often contain specific ingredients like biotin, keratin, and vitamins. Biotin is known to strengthen hair and reduce hair loss, as indicated by a study published in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology (Koehler et al., 2020). Keratin is a protein that forms the structure of hair, helping to fortify and protect strands from damage.

  2. Increasing moisture retention: Many hair density shampoos incorporate hydrating ingredients such as aloe vera and glycerin. Aloe vera soothes the scalp and maintains moisture levels, according to research published in the Journal of Ethnopharmacology (El-Shemy et al., 2015). Glycerin is a humectant that draws moisture from the air into the hair, making it appear plumper and more voluminous.

  3. Improving the overall scalp environment: A healthy scalp is crucial for hair growth. Hair density shampoos frequently include exfoliating components like salicylic acid or natural exfoliants like tea tree oil. These ingredients help to remove dead skin cells and excess oil. A clean scalp can promote better hair growth, as stated in the International Journal of Trichology (Agarwal et al., 2019).

  4. Strengthening hair strands: Ingredients such as amino acids and essential fatty acids can reinforce hair strength. Amino acids form the building blocks of proteins, directly impacting hair health. Studies show that these components can reduce breakage and improve hair elasticity (Yoon et al., 2019).

Through these mechanisms, hair density shampoos can create a fuller look by supporting healthier hair growth and optimizing hair structure.

What Key Ingredients Should You Look for in Hair Density Shampoos?

Key ingredients to look for in hair density shampoos include beneficial components that promote thicker and healthier hair.

  1. Biotin
  2. Keratin
  3. Caffeine
  4. Niacin (Vitamin B3)
  5. Saw Palmetto
  6. Essential oils (e.g., peppermint, rosemary)
  7. Panthenol (Vitamin B5)
  8. Amino acids

These ingredients offer various potential benefits, but perspectives on their effectiveness can vary. Some users may emphasize natural ingredients like essential oils, while others may prefer specific scientifically backed components like biotin and keratin. Preferences can influence choices based on individual hair types and needs.

  1. Biotin:
    Biotin is a B vitamin essential for hair health. It strengthens hair follicles and supports new hair growth. A study by H. W. C. Lee (2019) found that biotin supplementation improved hair thickness and reduced hair loss. Many people report positive results from shampoos containing biotin, as it is believed to enhance overall hair density.

  2. Keratin:
    Keratin is a structural protein found in hair. Hair density shampoos with keratin may help improve hair texture and strength. According to a study in the Journal of Cosmetic Science (2020), keratin-treated hair shows increased tensile strength and elasticity. Users often choose keratin-rich shampoos for smooth and voluminous hair.

  3. Caffeine:
    Caffeine stimulates hair follicles and promotes hair growth by increasing blood circulation to the scalp. Research published in the International Journal of Dermatology (2018) suggests that caffeine can encourage hair growth in both male and female patterns of baldness. Shampoos with caffeine are popular among those seeking thicker hair.

  4. Niacin (Vitamin B3):
    Niacin improves blood circulation and nourishes hair follicles. The American Academy of Dermatology notes that niacin may help improve hair density by enhancing follicle health. Users often report fuller-looking hair after using shampoos with this vitamin.

  5. Saw Palmetto:
    Saw palmetto is a natural extract that may inhibit the production of DHT, a hormone linked to hair loss. A study published in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (2014) indicated that saw palmetto could effectively prevent male pattern baldness. Some users favor shampoos containing saw palmetto for its natural approach to addressing thinning hair.

  6. Essential oils (e.g., peppermint, rosemary):
    Essential oils offer diverse benefits for hair density. Peppermint oil increases blood circulation, while rosemary oil enhances scalp health. Research published in the journal SkinMed (2015) indicates that rosemary oil is as effective as minoxidil, a common hair loss treatment, in promoting hair growth. Many consumers appreciate shampoos with these oils for their soothing properties.

  7. Panthenol (Vitamin B5):
    Panthenol hydrates and conditions hair, leading to a fuller appearance. According to the Journal of Investigative Dermatology (2016), panthenol can improve hair moisture and elasticity. Shampoos containing panthenol are often chosen for their ability to maintain hair health and density.

  8. Amino acids:
    Amino acids are the building blocks of proteins, including keratin. They help strengthen hair and improve its structure. A study in the International Journal of Trichology (2017) showed that amino acid supplementation can enhance hair growth and density. Many people opt for shampoos enriched with amino acids for their restorative qualities.

Are There Natural Ingredients That Effectively Promote Hair Density?

Yes, there are natural ingredients that effectively promote hair density. Ingredients such as biotin, saw palmetto, and rosemary oil are known for their potential to stimulate hair growth and improve thickness.

Biotin is a B-vitamin that promotes hair health. It supports the production of keratin, a protein that makes up hair structure. Saw palmetto is a plant extract that may prevent hair loss by inhibiting the hormone dihydrotestosterone (DHT), which contributes to hair thinning. Rosemary oil is an essential oil that increases blood circulation to the scalp, which may help in promoting hair growth. Together, these ingredients provide different yet complementary benefits.

The positive aspects of natural ingredients for hair density include their safety and potential effectiveness. Research shows that biotin can improve hair growth in individuals with deficiency. A study published in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology (2021) found that participants using topical rosemary oil experienced significant hair growth compared to those using a placebo. Additionally, DHT blockers like saw palmetto have shown promise in studies for reducing hair loss in men and women.

On the negative side, natural ingredients do not guarantee results for everyone. Some people may not respond to these treatments or may require more potent medical solutions. A review in the American Journal of Clinical Dermatology (2022) indicated that while natural products can be effective, some individuals may experience slow results or adverse reactions due to skin sensitivity, particularly with essential oils. Consulting a dermatologist is recommended to avoid potential interactions or side effects.

For individuals seeking to improve hair density, consider using products containing these natural ingredients. Look for hair care products specifically formulated with biotin and saw palmetto. Essential oils can be used in diluted forms as scalp massages. Additionally, ensure a balanced diet rich in vitamins and minerals to support overall hair health. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen, especially if there are underlying health concerns.

In What Ways Does Hair Density Shampoo Help Prevent Thinning Hair?

Hair density shampoo helps prevent thinning hair in several ways. It contains ingredients that nourish the scalp and hair follicles. These nutrients enhance blood circulation, which promotes healthy hair growth. The shampoo often includes biotin and keratin, which are essential for strong, resilient hair.

Additionally, it may feature botanical extracts that strengthen hair strands and reduce breakage. These natural components also provide hydration, making hair appear fuller and thicker. Regular use of hair density shampoo can improve the overall health of the hair, leading to less thinning over time. When the shampoo is used as part of a daily routine, it supports the hair’s natural growth cycle and helps maintain volume.

What Are the Top Benefits of Using Hair Density Shampoo Regularly?

Using hair density shampoo regularly provides several benefits.

  1. Increases hair thickness
  2. Promotes hair growth
  3. Nourishes the scalp
  4. Strengthens hair strands
  5. Reduces hair breakage
  6. Improves shine and manageability
  7. Balances oil production

Some users may experience varying results due to different hair types or underlying conditions. The perception of effectiveness may differ between individuals, with some desiring fast results and others focusing on overall scalp health. Understanding these perspectives is important for assessing the benefits of hair density shampoo.

  1. Increases Hair Thickness: Hair density shampoo increases the thickness of hair strands. It contains ingredients like biotin and keratin, which strengthen hair from within. A study by the Journal of Cosmetic Science in 2018 found that biotin can promote hair thickness and health.

  2. Promotes Hair Growth: Hair density shampoo may stimulate hair follicles to encourage growth. Ingredients such as caffeine and peppermint oil stimulate blood circulation in the scalp. Research published by the Institute of Dermatology in 2017 showed that caffeine can enhance hair shaft elongation.

  3. Nourishes the Scalp: Hair density shampoo nourishes the scalp, providing essential nutrients. Ingredients like aloe vera and argan oil hydrate and soothe the scalp, reducing irritations. A study by the International Journal of Trichology suggests that a well-nourished scalp is crucial for strong hair growth.

  4. Strengthens Hair Strands: Hair density shampoo strengthens hair by improving its elasticity and resilience. Proteins and vitamins in these shampoos repair damaged hair and prevent future breakage. The American Academy of Dermatology states that protein-rich products can help fortify hair.

  5. Reduces Hair Breakage: Hair density shampoo can minimize breakage, leading to healthier hair over time. This is achieved through moisturization and damage repair, supported by ingredients such as panthenol and silk proteins. According to a study by the British Journal of Dermatology, moisturizing agents can significantly decrease hair breakage.

  6. Improves Shine and Manageability: Hair density shampoo enhances the overall look and feel of hair. It adds shine and makes hair easier to style, resulting from ingredients like dimethicone and natural oils. A survey by Consumer Reports in 2019 indicated that users prefer products that provide both shine and manageability.

  7. Balances Oil Production: Hair density shampoo helps maintain healthy oil levels in the scalp. It prevents excessive oiliness or dryness, balancing the scalp’s environment for optimal hair health. The Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology highlights that scalp balance is crucial for preventing hair loss.

Using hair density shampoo regularly can lead to these significant benefits, although results may vary based on individual hair and scalp conditions.

How Do You Select the Best Hair Density Shampoo for Your Hair Type?

To select the best hair density shampoo for your hair type, consider factors such as hair thickness, scalp condition, ingredient effectiveness, and specific hair goals.

Hair thickness: Identify whether your hair is fine, medium, or thick. Fine hair may benefit from lightweight shampoos designed to add volume without weighing strands down. Thick hair, on the other hand, may require more moisturizing formulations that promote density and nourishment.

Scalp condition: Evaluate your scalp’s health. An oily scalp may require a clarifying or balancing shampoo to remove excess buildup, while a dry scalp may need a hydrating shampoo with added oils and nutrients to maintain moisture.

Ingredient effectiveness: Look for key ingredients that promote hair density. Ingredients like biotin, niacin, and caffeine have been shown to stimulate hair growth. A study published in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology (2017) found that caffeine can help extend the hair growth phase.

Specific hair goals: Determine your hair goals. If you want thicker hair, opt for shampoos labeled for density enhancement. If you are trying to address thinning hair, look for shampoos designed specifically to reduce hair loss. According to a study in the Journal of Dermatology (2019), shampoos containing saw palmetto can decrease levels of dihydrotestosterone (DHT), a hormone linked to hair loss.

Sensitivity: Ensure the product is suitable for your skin sensitivity. Conduct a patch test to check for adverse reactions, especially if you have a history of allergies or sensitive skin.

By analyzing these characteristics, you can choose a hair density shampoo that aligns with your specific hair type and care needs.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment